@MyraButterworth@IwanDoherty98 The price/yield is not some property of the physical geography of the UK. The reason Paris is much denser than London is because of regulation, which the government could change
@FlyingRadical@NoJusticeMTG@IwanDoherty98 How does deregulated bank lending lead to the number of homes per person barely increasing over 30 years? If anything you'd think that would make more money available to build new homes.
@cfwinstanley@timleunig@rcolvile The most important bit is supply. The attempts to make it more complex are a combination of confusing cause and effect, and small effects that are an order of magnitude less important than supply.
@wight1984 Doesn't "equality of outcomes" in your original screenshot shown that they are willing to do some of these things? That is explicitly beyond your interpretation of "the rules should actually be fair to everyone, rather than just appearing fair".
@moving_charlie@WasOnceLoved I'm confused why you think these are the metrics that determine whether there is a shortage. Why would the number of homes for sale determine whether there is a shortage or not? Or the number of vacant homes?
@johndotwills Consider all the permissions granted (say) 25 years ago. All the ones that ended up being viable are now built out. But still not enough housing was built from the permissions granted that year. The problem is the number of permissions or post-planning viability, not the timing.
@johndotwills "why Britain has a housing crisis" is much too strong a claim - absorption rate of a development only affects when the homes are built, not how many.
A site being completed over 10 years instead of 3 still provides the same amount of housing in the end.
@AngelaH58 Not sure if you think I am suggesting forcing people out their homes, but I'm not. I am pro building much more housing so that we don't have people claiming older people should be forced out for "fairness".
In April, the BBC featured an upcoming Report claiming that London's housing crisis is not caused by a shortage. The report (from Centre For London) has now been released. The analysis arguing for a lack of shortage is fundamentally broken. 🧵 bbc.co.uk/news/articles/…
@desso61 I don't know if you imagined that I said that, or if you're criticising distributional arguments that imply that should happen.
I'd much rather get housing for younger people by building huge amounts of homes rather than trying to force older people out in the name of "fairness".
@DanNeidle@HCH_Hill You have the correct definition. My point is that "owner occupiers gained floorspace" (if true) doesn't let us conclude that "rich new entrants gobble up new floorspace". We'd need to understand the age/tenure composition of the group before we could claim anything like that.
@johndotwills@Livingstone_RJ The Report is also very pro-market rate supply! The authors would almost certainly approve of the development that Southwark turned down. I can't understand how one would come away from reading it thinking that it implies applications like that should be turned down.
These errors mean one of the core conclusions of the Report is wrong. There is no counterintuitive observation to explain: Affordability and housing need have deteriorated due to an overwhelming increase in demand compared to supply, not because of a "winner takes all" dynamic.
There is no supply-side policy that can prevent older owner-occupiers continuing to live in their homes. Functional housing markets have space/homes-per-person rising over time; England and London do not.
147 Followers 3K FollowingToday, A 12 year-old came up to me and said "May I please have a cigarette?". I can`t believe kids this age are already so polite.
8K Followers 4K FollowingContributing Editor @TheCriticMag - sidelines in infrastructure project finance in Iraq, and manufacturing in the West Midlands.
649 Followers 667 FollowingChief economic advisor London Property Alliance; Chair of the Central District Alliance and Hatton Garden BIDs; Board member OPDC
172 Followers 2K FollowingI'm interested in nature restoration and forest governance. Quite optimistic that we can work out how to avoid the climate crisis.
537 Followers 2K FollowingYou see flags. You see names. You make assumptions. Oh, and if Mastodon and Bluesky were any good, you’d be there. Not here, reading this.
79K Followers 1K FollowingComedian that started Persona Essential, a comedy-forward social media marketing firm that specializes in organic viral content.
5K Followers 102 FollowingThe Ministry of Detail // Fixing the small stuff
Quibble is a non-profit campaign to fix overlooked public interest and consumer issues
8K Followers 4K FollowingContributing Editor @TheCriticMag - sidelines in infrastructure project finance in Iraq, and manufacturing in the West Midlands.
3K Followers 584 FollowingTalks about Social Housing, Economics, Government, now works in tech and global trade. Shipping guy. Red Dwarf Truther. “Criminally underfollowed”: John Stepek
6K Followers 1K FollowingCo-founder @Britishprogress / Working to put the UK at frontier of progress + achieve the highest living standards in the world / Views my own
5K Followers 4K FollowingInvestment & AI Adviser @ DSIT, Visiting Fellow @ Oxford Martin & Said Business School. Former YC founder, angel investor & No10 Downing Street adviser on AI
4K Followers 1K FollowingLewisham born and bred| Essayist| Bylines in @Telegraph @NewStatesman @unherd @spikedonline @spectator |Member of St Peter's Church, Brockley
618 Followers 1K FollowingTecwen Whittock. interested in economics, politics and the history of science. From a coal mining village--fairness, kindness, on the side of the underdog.
15K Followers 2K FollowingWhen the going gets weird the weird turn pro.
Researching and writing AI and other topics from a broadly EA perspective. On a grant from CG.
225 Followers 363 FollowingNo. 10 Downing Street Innovation Fellow | Research Scientist at AISI | Visiting Lecturer at Imperial College London
Working on AI Evaluation and AI for Medicine
6K Followers 377 FollowingDescribed as 'one of life's great magnetic personalities', 'the biggest eccentric in Westminster', 'an oddity from the 1950s' and 'intimidatingly self-aware'
646 Followers 499 FollowingDeputy Director, Research Unit, UK AISI. Generalist who enjoys getting difficult things done and trying to make the world less bad. Views mine, rt!=endorse
89K Followers 1K Following🕯️ In labouring to be concise, I become obscure.
🕯️ Alchemist, sacred things, making things
🌜 The map is mostly water.
https://t.co/7yYIMFg8iL ✦ https://t.co/1uOjdQwGV7
2K Followers 491 FollowingSystem cards, risk reports, and misc safety takes at Anthropic; math; puzzles; spaced repetition. Writes with too many caveats for Twitter.