Lynne Kiesling-Knowledge Problem @knowledgeprob

This is one of my favorite papers to teach rent-seeking and the relationship to economic growth. Its well argued and essentially also introduces multiple equilibria logic to students in simple mathematics.

Very well written piece on AI and copyright, and an important trade-off that we should take very seriously. open.substack.com/pub/srajagopal…

I strongly endorse this outstanding report, commissioned by Daniel Diermeier, Chancellor of Vanderbilt University, and Andrew Martin, Chancellor of Washington University on the State of Scholarship. It is a cri de couer about the state of the humanities and the interpretive social sciences. The object of scrutinty is "a deterioration in scholarly standards fueled by the substitution of political criteria for properly scholarly criteria in the assessment of research and a more general repudiation of longstanding ideals of rigor and objectivity." The report is properly nuanced in identifying subfields in which the scholarly enterprise has been damaged and as opposed to blanket disciplinary condemnations because of problems in particular areas. vanderbilt.edu/principles/sta…

@sebkrier Absolutely the case with energy and electricity regulation and technological change.

People do not coordinate only through broad legal rules and prices. Hayek emphasized abstract rules that allow people to coordinate like property, contract, trade, and competition. But Lachmann also emphasized the practical secondary institutions people orient their plans around, like banks, standardized contracts, product categories, and so on. In software, an abstraction boundary is an interface that hides complexity hiding beneath. In this 2005 paper (papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cf…), Miller and Tulloh explain that you can apply this concept to markets too. Consider a post office: there's an abstract boundary that separates why the customer wants to mail something (which the postman doesn't need to know); what the shared transaction is (all the recognizable steps and commitments involved in sending mail); and how the postal system actually delivers it (complex logistics network hidden from the customer). The middle part is what lets the user benefit from the postal system’s expertise without having to learn postal logistics. The boundary defines the shared 'what' but also separates the customer’s 'why' from the provider’s 'how'. Not only that, but reusability means the same institution can be used to satisfy many purposes (birthday invites, subpoenas etc) and polymorphism means different providers can satisfy the same need and compete (UPS, FedEx etc). An important question in institutional theory is how societies achieve both stability and adaptation; the paper authors say that the solution is stable interfaces allow changing internals. I find this very intuitive: when companies don't evolve/change from the inside much, you get ossification and insufficient adaptation. When laws change too much and institutions are unstable, uncertainty affects market confidence. The people who are good at redrawing abstraction boundaries are entrepreneurs, who notice when existing categories are wrong and will invent new ones to remedy faults or address demand. What has always saddened me is how poorly rewarded and incentivized political entrepreneurship is. Part of the reason why is that this is hard: market abstraction boundaries are often disciplined by exit, entry, profit/loss, customer choice, and provider competition - but these feedback loops are much weaker in the public sector. I hope we'll see a lot more of this in the coming decade. In fact this is something that AI will hugely facilitate, since it can lower the cost of articulating and prototyping new abstraction boundaries. We've already seen minor examples through e.g. citizens creating websites/services that compete with government ones. Though usually this is to make state services more legible rather than changing the boundaries in the first place. I think if people want the future to go well, bolstering state capacity and enabling more innovation on the governance/democracy side of things will be critical. People don't really like this because it's a slow process, but I think they're wrong (and cheems), and playing the 'urgency of AGI' card to bypass this through a de facto state of emergency will cause lasting harms, partly by weakening institutional learning, public trust, and future coordination capacity.

"The tragedy of our present moment is not merely that Americans disagree passionately. Democracies are supposed to contain passionate disagreement. The tragedy is that many citizens increasingly struggle to imagine political opponents as participants in a shared constitutional project, which is precisely why Tocqueville matters today." @knowledgeprob with a terrific #reading project for #America250... Reading Tocqueville. open.substack.com/pub/knowledgep…

Fun model and very much in line with my priors. Problems arrive stochastically. Some orgs choose new processes to solve them. Costly to know when the problem is no longer active, hence costly to prune. Rule: be firm to not institutionalize solutions to temporary problems.

Vicky C Yang @VickyCYang

a week ago

Between 1985--2023, MIT's faculty grew 9%. Administrative staff grew 189%. 📈 Why? In new @PNASNews paper, we use dynamical system model to show administrative bloat can emerge without empire-building--just from well-intentioned problem-solving gone awry pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pn…

25 208 834 166K 481

ERCOT low key sitting with the highest reserve margin of the major North American grids this summer according to NERC: Given an Anticipated Reserve Margin of 67.9% and Reference Reserve Margin of 13.75%, ERCOT expects to have sufficient operating reserves... nerc.com/globalassets/o…

knowledgeproblem.substack.com/p/reading-tocq…

I'm celebrating the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence by rereading Tocqueville's Democracy in America. Please join me. Few thinkers have understood as deeply the relationship between liberty, civil society, local institutions, and democratic self-government.

@mungowitz Thank you, sir!

I've read a bunch of dumb commentaries on data centers. Interesting to read a smart one. From @knowledgeprob substack.com/home/post/p-19…

🧵 Agree 💯 this is a great innovative direction.

Arushi Sharma Frank @ArushiSF

a week ago

Flex consumption over capped low pwr consumption means:, AI can use ⚡ headroom + curtail to a floor in response to locational congestion. Three weeks ago, I introduced @ERCOT_ISO & @SantaClaraPower (Silicon Valley PWR) colleagues to one another. Pushing grid-aware load ops is

1 0 4 2K 5

Beautifully done. Evolution of women’s fashions.

Good coverage and clear to anyone paying attention to these markets over the last 18 months. PJM came within 2GW of forcing data centers onto backup power last week. Summer heat drove peak load past 135GW with reserves at 4%, and 40GW of generation sat in maintenance. DOE only cleared a voluntary switchover this time. Writing is on the wall: When the grid hits peak conditions, data centers lose service first. Texas already wrote that into law with SB6. Half the US pipeline sits in PJM and Texas. Takeaway: Interruptible service is becoming the price of a fast interconnect.

keyboard_arrow_left Previous keyboard_arrow_right Next

🧵

Michael Giberson @MichaelGiberso3

2 weeks ago

At a recent Cato Institute event @ENERGY Sec Chris Wright spoke warmly of his friendship and respect for Milton Friedman. It’s likely that Professor Friedman would not be a fan of DOE’s use of emergency authority to block the retirement of old power plants across the country.🧵

1 3 24 2K 1

@SlBrandin Well said!

🧵, although I would de-emphasize the "perfect" in the competition concept.

Sam @SlBrandin

2 weeks ago

When people say they want “abundance” what they really mean is they want robust and competitive free markets which can readily respond to price signals incentivizing new supply and technological innovation when demand calls for it. This concept gets simplified into the notion

1 4 13 3K 2

Welcome to my power bill 😬.

Travis Kavulla @TKavulla

2 weeks ago

ComEd customers seeing the PJM "uplift" costs (out-of-market payments for gas plants during Winter Storm Fern early this year) on their bill this month. The cost of the surcharge (the "purchased electricity adjustmnet") is literally > than the cost of electricity this month

4 5 29 12K 12

I've written a @claudeai skill that is useful when you’re starting a new project and want to absorb fifty papers before writing a word yourself. /tyler converts a folder of academic PDFs into a token-efficient markdown wiki for literature review. Point it at a directory of papers and it produces one lightweight .md file per paper, plus an index, so Claude Code can load an entire literature into context without burning tokens on raw PDF parsing. Named in honour of @tylercowen, the economist behind @MargRev and a famously voracious reader. Available from --> johanfourie.com/econtools.html